Excerpt from The Ultimates. Art by Bryan Hitch, Paul Neary, and Laura Martin. Photo: Brian Hitch; Paul Neary/Marvel entertain
practically exactly 15 year ago, Marvel Comics released a comic containing one of the an ext alarming pages they’ve ever before published. In the final act of The Ultimates No. 3, Captain America — the superhero who claims to was standing for all that’s good and righteous around his nation — attends a Washington, D.C., gala and encounters George W. Bush. “Well, what’s her verdict on the 21st century, Captain America? Cool or uncool?” shrub asks.

You are watching: Do you think this a stands for france

Cool, pops President,” lid replies. “Definitely cool.” as cameras flash, the Sentinel that Liberty proudly and enthusiastically salutes Dubya.

To look in ~ that page today, in an era as soon as the popular conception that Captain America is that of a morally unambiguous, charmingly hopeful number on screens roughly the world, is to feel a frisson that horror. To do matters worse, the scene is free of mind manage or angry cloning — Steve is doing precisely what he desires to do once he defers come the leader that the Republican Party and icon the the neoconservative movement. ~ above one hand, it feels wholly the end of character: Why would Captain America it is in so chummy through such a war-loving crusader? but then you think to yourself, Wait … no Captain America, himself, a little bit of a war-loving crusader?

The scene, like every one of Ultimates, is designed to make you uncomfortable — something superhero fiction generally doesn’t carry out well. Written by mark Millar and penciled by Bryan Hitch, The Ultimates was set outside that the tendency Marvel universe, in a civilization that much an ext closely resembled our own and where the company’s classic personalities were just just beginning out your careers. The eponymous squadron in The Ultimates was a new-millennium riff ~ above the personalities from Marvel’s long-running superteam the Avengers, and it to be equal parts thrilling and also unsettling. The recipe made for one of the many remarkable story to ever before be called in the superhero genre.

That genre has advanced in a great many ways during its eight years of existence: dialogue has become less stilted; artwork has become more varied; representation of marginalized groups has increased (though yes still lot farther to go on the front); and also film, not print, has come to be the dominant medium for tales of paranormal derring-do. But an ext often than not, superhero stories on page and screen alike room designed to go down smoothly, earnestly putting us ~ above the next of the heroes, every little thing their relatable shortcomings might be. What’s more, the an essential notion the altruistic heroism — that such a concept can also exist — is taken together a given. Those stories, themselves, space not a problem; the absence of a counterbalance is.

Thank goodness, then, because that The Ultimates. This serialized epos was released by Marvel Comics in 2 volumes across 28 installments over the food of the aughts, through its very first chapter debuting in at an early stage 2002 (there were succeeding volumes, yet none done by the original an innovative team and every one of them fairly tonally different from the early stretch). Its business impact is indisputable: The collection looked and sounded choose a movie in a method that no Marvel story ever had and, therefore, acted together the major blueprint because that what would later end up being the globally dominant Marvel Cinematic Universe. The said, a decade and a half after it explosive onto stands, the artistic and thematic heritage is much harder to parse. The Ultimates is, in a word, attack — and that’s what provides it one of the most necessary superhero stories of all time. For every its flaws — and also they are many — in our present entertainment and also political climate, the story is maybe more an important than ever.


*

Excerpt from The Ultimates. Art by Bryan Hitch, Paul Neary, and also Laura Martin. Photo: Marvel entertain

In various other words, this Captain America to be a personification the the Bush-era American self-image. The characterization plot as among the most brutally discomfiting critiques of American machismo ever before told in superhero fiction. I say “acts as” and not “was created to be” because it’s hard to suss out the purposes of the book’s stare craftsman. Millar has actually said he was being vital of conservatism, yet he has a nasty habit that dissembling in interviews, therefore one can’t be as well sure as soon as he talks about his imaginative motives.

What is certain is the Millar is just one of the comics medium’s greatest provocateurs, and also whatever his intent, The Ultimates is politically disturbing in a method that also American cinema seldom dared to be in the immediate aftermath of 9/11. It depicts the country’s an initial line of defense together a repertoire of sadists and also assholes, every one of whom autumn in line through the Bushite neoconservative agenda for various unsavory reasons: wanting access to an R&D budget, wanting to admire a girlfriend, not knowing exactly how to not fight all the time, and so on. Not even liberals room safe: In a brilliant touch, Thor is depicted as a europe peacenik that convinces himself the joining this armed forces coalition doesn’t weaken his for free values, thus becoming a superpowered exemplar of what brand-new York Times alumnus bill Keller dubbed the “I-Can’t-Believe-I’m-a-Hawk Club.”

That politically urged superheroism becomes much more explicit together The Ultimates go on, and also it climaxes v an unbelievable violent commentary on American adventurism. About midway through the saga, the team room dispatched to Iran in order come dismantle its military. They do so bloodlessly, but they do innocents into enemies. A reedy local boy called Abdul watches in fear as the American invaders do together they will through his country, then, in a horrible subversion the the standard Captain America origin story, join a super-soldier regimen so he can become strong enough to stand up to the U.S.’s royal caprice. That regimen turns out to be component of a covert initiative by the governments of China, Russia, north Korea, and also Syria to construct their very own superpowered coalition the the willing. They call themselves the Liberators and also they effort to struggle the Iraq battle in reverse, it spreads widespread regime adjust in a belligerent and unchecked floor of the Brave.

The Ultimates loss the Liberators, yet their victory throughout a battle in Washington, D.C. — breathtakingly calculation by Hitch, inker Paul Neary, and colorist Laura young name — is alarming in the cynicism. A drunk Iron guy hops into a fight suit the size of one office building and also starts firing, unconcerned about the insane collateral damage he’s causing. Lid executes Abdul in former of the Vietnam Veterans Memorial, refusing to hear to his center Eastern counterpart’s decent critique the American foreign policy. Hank had actually turned traitor and also contributed android warriors to the Liberators, yet when it’s clear the tide is turning, he turn off them down and also cravenly pretends it was all an attempt to infiltrate America’s enemies. The Hulk goes up versus a fellow scientist-cum-monster that possesses Hulk’s strength but retains a genius intellect; the Hulk simply punches the guy’s skull apart when yelling, “YOU THINK too MUCH!


*

All as well often, superhero stories make the very same mistake of presume a priori righteousness, however they do so without any interrogation of that mind-set. It’s a general trouble for people — we want to think we’re law right, so us come up for righteous justifications because that our actions and also desires. The was what make the political critiques the neoconservatism for this reason potent, and also what provides them lasting power in our existing age of renewed American disdain for the rest of the world. Could once again makes right, and there’s always been a thin psychological line in between identifying v a fictional superhero and also a geopolitical superpower. Those who take jingoistic positions, favor the Ultimates, become convinced that there can be no to win argument against the nobility of their cause. Writers and directors of big-budget super-pictures generally think this around the reasons of the heroes lock write, too.

It’s a danger perspective, but one through a long history in the superhero genre. As comics movie critic Tegan O’Neil* as soon as pointed out, Superman’s best superpower is his positing the pure heroism can even exist in the an initial place. Sure, depicting Supes’ distinctive brand of pure quality is hard to do on film, but our cinematic and also televised super-people practically universally lean towards his finish of the hero-villain spectrum. We desire to believe that together virtue is possible, and it’s noble to aspire towards such altruism. Yet we mortals don’t have actually the superpower of gift purely good, or also necessarily of identifying what is good. That’s a quandary worth pondering, but sadly, few comics in the intervening years have actually attempted to be as discomfiting and also morally an overwhelming as The Ultimates. Sure, there room stories about an excellent guys rotate bad, but few about good guys who were bad even when they were good. Even subsequent Ultimates story lacked the politics valence and also innovation that the initial stretch. That lack only provides the initial tale every the much more urgent, both as a story and as an object of study. You should hope to be an Avenger, however be ready for the reality that you might slip up and become an Ultimate.

*A previous version of this article misstated Tegan O’Neil’s name.

See more: Europe Black And White Map, Europe Black & White Reference Map


top top the Uncomfortable Brilliance of Marvel’s The Ultimates Every product is individually selected through (obsessive) editors. Things you buy with our links may earn us a commission.